Should I buy an electronic keyboard or a piano ?

When you love the piano 

Acoustic piano

The piano has been around for ages. I am referring to what is really an acoustic instrument. It can come as an upright piano, as shown left, or a grand piano as shown to the right .

upright

They both have the same keyboard layout but the difference is visible in the form and style. The upright contains working parts laid out in an upright cabinet while the grand piano has part housed in furniture that can be opened, as might be seen at concert halls.

 There are so many models over the years but basically the structure has been the same the main features being :

  • pedals
  • dampers
  • keyboard with 88 black and white keys made from ivory
  • strings that vibrate when the keys are pressed and the hammer strikes
  • durable wood

Some people just love the acoustic piano. In addition to the sound it produces and the acoustic effects, some people like the elegance of the upright or the grand piano and how it enhances the decor. I have been to homes where there is a beautiful piano and the owner cannot play a tune. Several years ago, the decision to buy a piano was mainly a comparison of the style colour and finish of carpentry, the sound which was that of one instrument, and the cost or brand.

As you all know, inventions have brought options to the piano, which we will discuss later. I am conversant with the inventions but there is something very soulful and sweet about sitting at a piano, caressing those notes which respond to your emotional expressions of touch.

When an acoustic piano takes its place in your home, you will be required to have it positioned away from moisture and extreme cold. All the parts are built for long service, but this piano requires regular tuning by an expert, with repair and servicing over the long term.

How does it compare to the digital instrument 

The piano has evolved to a device that is far more than ‘a piano’. electronic pianos

It is an electronic instrument that can sample and deliver, not only sounds of almost all instruments, but also rhythms for accompaniment across all percussion, and preset styles. The main features are:

  • electrical connection
  • connection to an amplifier to augment the sound
  • one touch adjustments in tones and rhythms
  • metronome guidance
  • hundreds of instruments (voices)
  • ability to combine several instruments in various proportions
  • a variety of sizes, models with simple to advanced features

The sizes range from 61 to 88 keys. The output is related to the degree of sensitivity of the notes. There are those with weighted keys, semi- weighted keys and light. There is a wide range of prices related to brands and complexity of features and those, along with personal preferences, determine what keyboard you should buy.

The digital piano is designed to enhance the playing experience. Because the practicing is not just learning, but also fun, it encourages the student, hobbyist, or stage performer, to spend more time creating sounds and accompanying simple melodies. keys

One of the main attractions of the digital piano is the option of lighter instruments and therefore portability. One has to wonder what used to happen for rehearsals and performances when pianos were heavy and would get out of tune if moved from one venue to another.

Another advantage is that of being a workstation. Compositions and loops can be recorded as files and stored on the instrument or on a remote computer.

The factor of cost is also one to consider as an intermediate student could opt for a simple 61 key piano and a professonal might prefer one with weighted keys  and more advanced settings with programming, recording and file storage.

Is the electronic keyboard better?

As described above, ‘better’ depends on the preferences, and the needs of the buyer. With all the advancements in keyboards, there are still many professionals who play only on a grand piano, and there are many people who want only an upright piano in their homes.

If you wish to purchase an instrument, take note of the discussion above. Take a look at some recommendations and open the links to Youtube so you can watch someone explain and demonstrate the features, while you can hear some of the voices and the depth of each instrument.

Learn more at https://mypianohobby.com/

Please follow and like us:
error0

12 Comments

  1. Rodarrick

    To me, an electronic piano would always rank better, because it gives so much ease and better performance. I actually learned with a standard piano that is full size. However, ever since the inception of the electronic piano, they have taken over and offer much more variations and better options. Thanks so much for sharing this detail. 

    Reply
    1. Joy (Post author)

      Roderick, it all comes down to the preferences of the buyer. Thank you for your comments

      Reply
  2. John

    This is utterly magnificent honestly and I haven’t come upon this kind of information before. The thing is that I am thinking of starting a lesson in music so I was wondering what I should get. but I think using the electronic keyboard will be my best pick right now. I will go onto check out your recommendations. Thanks

    Reply
    1. Joy (Post author)

      Go right ahead, John. Keep up with those lessons and you will be proud of yourself in a short while.

      Reply
  3. Henry

    Hi! I have had this discussion. And although there are those that firmly advocate for a piano I believe that the best choice for me is an electronic keyboard. As you explained, it all comes down to the buyers need. But I appreciate you have made me view things with a different perspective after reading your post. Thanks.

    Reply
    1. Joy (Post author)

      Oh yes it does, Henry. Thanks for your comments.

      Reply
  4. Danijel

    Hello Joy, I must say that this article is very helpful and informative. I like to play the piano and I have one in my house although I have never tried the electronic one. I should definitely try the electronic keyword as often people invite me to play on birthdays and weddings, I like it is not expensive compared to its features. Thank you for sharing!

    Reply
    1. Joy (Post author)

      Thanks for your comments Danijel. It is clear that you can play well enough to perform at birthdays and weddings. The portability and price might attract you and it truly is a great investment.

      Reply
  5. Rodarrick

    Just like the good old days, a piano would always remain the best but then, to blend with the contemporary music, I will say the keyboard is surely better than a piano when looking at the various advancements and beautification that makes it what it is. To me, I like the keyboard better. What I like most is that it can play different instruments and even blend them. Thanks

    Reply
    1. Joy (Post author)

      Thanks for your comments. Have fun with your electronic piano

      Reply
  6. Shelley

    To say the truth, the electronic keyboard is my pick any day. The level at which it has been fine-tuned and developed has made it much better than most instruments. It is like the basis for all instruments to find their harmony. Though the grand piano still retains the classic and elegant features, but for any modern player who enjoys versatility and mobility, every one would go for the keyboard. Thanks

    Reply
    1. Joy (Post author)

      Yes Shelly, the electronic keyboard offers a lot in a small package.

      Reply

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *